What do people think of Lori Gottleib's
article on self-esteem and "helicopter parenting" in this month's
Atlantic? I haven't finished it yet (only able to read snatches here and there in the stolen moments between spoonfeeding my kids their pre-masticated dinners and crowing over their abilities to fit together two Lego blocks) but am finding it oddly compelling.
In general, have you noticed the little
backlash against self-esteem and even
against "positive thinking" that seems to be hitting the parenting and teachering world? Suddenly our
vast overprotection efforts are threatening to produce kids who are
fragile and dependent and ultimately unhappy! Ruin their
character!
Destroy their thinking abilities! Let
Asian tiger cubs eat their (organic, peanut-free) lunch! I am enjoying all of this hand-wringing mightily. I'll admit it has not yet much affected my own parenting style, which may be "tough love" by East Arlington standards but certainly looks more indulgent than some members of the older generation might be comfortable with. (But why should everyone always be
comfortable?) Then again, I also mightily enjoyed the anti-breastfeeding backlash of a few years ago, eagerly reading the latest screed by
Jill Lepore or
Hanna Rosin as I pumped. It's just nice to have someone question the pieties.
I should tell you one thing about Henry, though. It's not that he can't take criticism. It's that he doesn't have a sense of context for criticism: doesn't understand why two similar observations can can be "teasing" or "not a very nice comment" or "something that could hurt someone's feelings" in school (where they work
very hard on these things) but a constructive and actually necessary piece of feedback when, for instance, you are practicing ukulele and your mom would like to tell you that at a particular place in the song you are playing the wrong chord. We waste a huge amount of practicing time in temper tantrums this way. Yet I see the teachers at his school correct the kids (without being perceived as criticizing them) all the time. Is it only with me that Henry takes it so personally? And am I supposed to take that as some sick and perverse type of compliment?
Tonight.
Me: Henry, can I tell you something about the song you just played?
Henry: Is it going to make me unhappy?
Me: It shouldn't. It's just something to help you play the song better next time.
H: Then it's going to make me unhappy.
M: But why? (
Pause. Should I do this?) You know, I happen to be reading an article right now that says parents should be honest with kids about things like that. It says that actually kids are strong. And smart. And they can figure out what to do with it.
H: I'm not strong.
M: So they don't have to get worried when someone makes a comment to help them do something better.
H: I know what you're going to say: that I shouldn't be so "sensitive to every little thing." But I'm not. It's just you. You say all this really bad stuff.
M: Really? Okay. Well. The article also says it's okay for kids to get mad at their mommies and daddies sometimes. So... do you want to play the song again? (
He eventually does. By now it is almost bedtime.)
Would love to hear what my friends and relatives with younger and older kids think about all this.
Just please, no one say anything critical about my parenting -- I'm not sure I could take it! :)